Our Idaho Podiatrists Provide Some Suggestions on How to Secure Insurance Coverage for Custom Orthotics

While custom orthotics are a non-invasive and often effective solution for many common foot conditions, it’s only natural to worry about the cost. At Rocky Mountain Foot & Ankle in Caldwell and Meridian, patients frequently ask us if their insurance helps cover these specialized medical devices.

The good news is that many insurance plans do provide coverage for custom orthotics when prescribed by a qualified podiatrist. However, coverage details vary significantly between providers and plans. Here are our tips for researching your benefits and deciphering the process.

Understanding Insurance Requirements for Custom Orthotics Insurance Coverage for Custom Orthotics | Experienced Idaho Podiatrist

Accommodative and functional orthotics offer numerous benefits and might be solutions for many of your foot problems.

Unfortunately, having your customized inserts approved isn't as simple as walking into our office and requesting a prescription. Insurers have strict guidelines to ensure these medical devices are truly necessary for your condition. 

Understanding these requirements ahead of time helps streamline the approval process and prevent unexpected denials. Most insurance companies require specific documentation. Your podiatrist must demonstrate that these devices are medically necessary, not just a comfort item. Here’s a brief overview of typical qualifying records: 

  • A detailed diagnosis of your foot condition.
  • Proof of previous conservative treatments.
  • Physical examination findings.
  • Imaging results, such as X-rays or MRI scans.
  • Biomechanical evaluation results.
  • Prescription specifying the type of orthotic needed.

However, even when your health insurance covers custom orthotics, there may be specific restrictions that affect your out-of-pocket costs. Being aware of these limitations ahead of time helps you plan accordingly and avoid unexpected expenses. 

Here are some of the potential restrictions: 

  • Annual or lifetime maximums
  • Waiting periods between replacements
  • Exclusions for certain conditions
  • Limitations on materials or types of orthotics
  • Requirements for trying conservative treatments first

Our team can help you understand these guidelines and develop a treatment plan that maximizes your insurance benefits.

8 Key Questions to Ask Your Insurance Provider

Coverage varies widely between plans, even within the same company. Your plan might alter certain benefits eligibility year-by-year, too. So, once you’ve had a consultation with one of our Idaho foot doctors about why you need custom orthotics, it’s essential to do some additional legwork to understand the full scope of your policy. This helps you make informed decisions about your care—and prevents surprise bills from popping up later. 

Before scheduling your custom orthotic fitting, contact your insurance company to verify coverage details such as:

  1. Does the plan cover custom orthotics when prescribed by a podiatrist?
  2. What medical conditions qualify for coverage?
  3. Is pre-authorization required?
  4. Is there a deductible to meet first?
  5. What is the coverage percentage or copay amount?
  6. What are the stipulations regarding in-network and out-of-network provider coverage?
  7. How many pairs are covered per year or benefit period?
  8. Are there preferred providers or manufacturers?

Why Insurance Often Excludes Over-the-Counter Orthotics

Will your policy cover over-the-counter insoles? Not likely. The distinction comes down to medical necessity and professional oversight. Understanding this difference helps you make better decisions about your foot care and avoid wasting money on solutions that won't provide long-term relief.

Insurance companies typically don't cover non-prescription insoles because:

  • There’s a lack of a specific remedy. Even if retail inserts are advertised to address conditions such as plantar fasciitis and other heel pain or problems related to bursitis, as just two examples, they aren’t customized to properly resolve these and other medical issues as they relate to your feet.
  • The generalized fit. While there might be a range of off-the-shelf options, these orthotics don’t offer the precise measurements and modifications you need for effective support and correction.  
  • They’re non-prescriptive. Retail insoles are considered comfort items rather than medical devices.

As a point of comparison, the custom orthotics we offer at Rocky Mountain Foot & Ankle:

  • Run as little as half the retail cost.
  • May be covered by Medicaid.

How Our Idaho Custom Orthotics Specialists Provide the Necessary Documentation for Insurance Approval

Our detailed approach to this process helps ensure you can access what you're entitled to under your plan. So, to expand on what we mentioned above, once you have a better understanding of your policy requirements, our Idaho podiatrists will carefully document your case to support insurance coverage including, but not limited to:

  • Medical history related to your foot condition
  • Physical examination findings
  • Gait analysis results
  • Detailed measurements and impressions of your feet
  • Specific diagnosis codes
  • Treatment plan showing medical necessity
  • Progress notes demonstrating response to treatment

Our staff is happy to respond to your questions and requests about collecting the right information. 

Ultimately, we want you to feel more in control of all solutions available to you to alleviate troublesome foot issues. It’s worth a call to us—and to your insurer—to learn what options are available for your best care.

Dr. P. Roman Burk
Providing experienced private practice podiatry services in the Caldwell and Meridian, ID area since 2007.